The shape is the real difference
Both Bumkins Nintendo teethers share the same material, age range, and care instructions. The meaningful choice is the silhouette your baby will hold and chew: the Game Boy is a wider, flatter rectangle, while the NES Controller is a longer, narrower bar. That changes how the teether sits in little hands and which edges reach the gums.
Neither record lists a gum-soothing claim or a recommended chewing duration, so treat shape as a preference, not a performance guarantee.
What each teether is designed for
- Silicone Teether: Game Boy™: Inspired by the Nintendo Game Boy and sized for little hands and mouths, with textures for exploration and chewing. The wide, flat Game Boy shape gives a baby a broad surface to grip and mouth.

Silicone Teether: Game Boy™ - Silicone Teether: NES™ Controller: Inspired by Nintendo's NES Controller and sized for little hands and mouths, with textures for exploration and chewing. The longer controller shape offers a different grip and chewing orientation than the Game Boy.

Silicone Teether: NES™ Controller
Game Boy vs NES Controller at a glance
- Game Boy silicone teether: Wider, flatter Game Boy-inspired shape; 100% food-safe silicone; for ages 3 months and up; textured for sensory exploration; designed in Arizona and responsibly made in China.
- NES Controller silicone teether: Longer, narrower NES Controller-inspired shape; 100% food-safe silicone; for ages 3 months and up; textured for sensory exploration; designed in Arizona and responsibly made in China.
- Shared material and safety testing: Both are made from 100% food-safe (FDA) silicone and safety tested by certified third-party labs to comply with US Federal CPSC safety regulations for lead, phthalates, BPA, BPS, and cadmium.
- Shared care: Both can be cleaned with soap and water, are dishwasher safe on the top rack only, and can be boiled to sterilize.
Cleaning and supervision rules that apply to both
The care routine is identical, so you do not need to choose based on cleaning. Wash either teether with soap and water, run it on the top rack of the dishwasher, or boil it to sterilize. Silicone has a natural resistance to bacteria, according to the product records, which supports a simple wash-and-reuse routine.
Both records state the teether is not a toy and requires adult supervision. Inspect it regularly for damage and discard it immediately if it is damaged or torn. Neither record specifies a replacement interval, so inspection is your main check.
Care and safety evidence
- Silicone Teether: Game Boy™: Made from 100% food-safe silicone and does not contain any petroleum-based plastics or toxic chemicals. Material is the same across both teethers, so it should not drive your choice.
- Silicone Teether: NES™ Controller: Dishwasher safe on the top rack only and can be safely boiled to sterilize. Confirms the shared cleaning routine so you can decide on shape alone.
Age, availability, and gift considerations
Both teethers are listed for ages 3 months and up, so the age range does not separate them. The records do not confirm suitability for babies under 3 months, and they do not make any feeding, sleep, or developmental claims.
If you are buying as a baby shower gift for gamers, the retro reference is the appeal. Note that Nintendo products are not discount eligible and are only available to the United States and its territories, Canada, UK, Mexico, Australia, New Zealand, and China. Check that the recipient's location is covered before ordering.
The catalog lists the Game Boy at USD 7.36 and the NES Controller at USD 6.87, with a comparison price of USD 9.95 for each. Prices can change, so confirm at checkout.
How to choose between the two
- Choose the Game Boy if: You want a wider, flatter teether that may suit a baby who grips with the whole hand, or you prefer the Game Boy nostalgia.
- Choose the NES Controller if: You want a longer, narrower shape that may be easier to angle toward the back gums, or you prefer the controller look.
- Choose either if: Your priority is food-safe silicone, simple cleaning, and a supervised teething aid for a baby 3 months or older.



